MyLifeIsAverage

Life is pretty normal today.
Today, I remembered a story my uncle told me. During science one year, his class learned how two brown-eyed parents couldn't have a blue-eyed baby. After hearing this, a blue-eyed girl burst out crying. MLIA
#641430 Comments: 82 Vote: average 8208meh 713Share 
[ - ]  MobileGood: 15Bad: 32 years ago
Someone's an affair baby!
 
[ - ]  TheScareCrowGood: 7Bad: 12 years ago
*bribes Mobile* Just don't tell anyone. *shifty eyes*
 
[ - ]  CoCoCourtneyGood: 0Bad: 02 years ago
or adopted xD
 
[ - ]  Text_on_the_screenGood: 19Bad: 02 years ago
Because a grandparent had blue eyes... Oh, was I not supposed to tell the truth?
 
[ - ]  BelaLugosiGood: 3Bad: 02 years ago
The OP can't handle the truth!
 
[ - ]  GortehGood: 5Bad: 02 years ago
Can you smell what my pet rock is cooking?
 
[ - ]  Text_on_the_screenGood: 8Bad: 02 years ago
Your pet rock can cook? Mine just sits there. Plotting to run away.
 
[ - ]  GortehGood: 6Bad: 02 years ago
Yes, right now it's cooking a delicious smelling lasagna.
 
[ - ]  Text_on_the_screenGood: 4Bad: 02 years ago
AUGH!!! I was gonna say lasagna. That sounds so good right now.
 
[ - ]  lafunny84Good: 0Bad: 92 years ago
its still not possible
 
[ - ]  heatherrawrieeGood: 51Bad: 02 years ago
But... they can? Basic genetics fail.
 
[ - ]  GortehGood: 47Bad: 02 years ago
Clearly. Parents could be heterozygous and pass on the blue-eyed allele. Ooooh, I'm getting sciencey there.
 
[ - ]  Text_on_the_screenGood: 28Bad: 02 years ago
It's actually funny how dumb this teacher would have to be, to teach kids that this is impossible.
 
[ - ]  averagekittehGood: 34Bad: 02 years ago
I've seen a few stories about teachers saying this and I'm always like No!! faail AaxAa= 1/4 AA, 1/2 Aa, and 1/4 aa<-OMG BLUE EYED CHILD
 
[ - ]  JeNieDieu42Good: 9Bad: 32 years ago
Perhaps OP meant that two blue-eyed people can't have a brown-eyed child?
 
[ - ]  lylacupcakeGood: 7Bad: 02 years ago
Yep yep. I just did a Punnett square worksheet on how there IS a 25% chance of 2 brown-eyed heterozygous parents having a homozygous recessive blue-eyed baby. :D But of course, our teacher made a worksheet with Disney characters such as Lady and the Tramp, Daisy/Donald Duck, etc. :P
 
[ - ]  MobileGood: 3Bad: 22 years ago
Good stuff, good stuff... Science is fun.
 
[ - ]  heatherrawrieeGood: 5Bad: 22 years ago
And I knew what you meant! *sicence dance-your-pants-off rave*
 
[ - ]  GortehGood: 1Bad: 02 years ago
*science.
 
[ - ]  heatherrawrieeGood: 3Bad: 12 years ago
Ooh, spelling fail. Thanks for catching that.
 
[ - ]  GortehGood: 2Bad: 22 years ago
No problem, luv.
 
[ - ]  escualidaGood: 12Bad: 02 years ago
maybe they got confused and it was actually the other way around? 2 blue eyed parents can't have a brown eyed child... right?
 
[ - ]  mynameiserikGood: 0Bad: 02 years ago
That was my thought...or my hope, rather...
 
[ - ]  VampPyrateGood: 0Bad: 12 years ago
seriously...just because its a recessive trait doesn't mean its impossible...its just a smaller percentage
 
[ - ]  TheScareCrowGood: 5Bad: 32 years ago
It's funny because no one loves her.
 
[ - ]  GortehGood: 2Bad: 22 years ago
Haha, it's so true!
 
[ - ]  merrysongstressGood: 20Bad: 02 years ago
*grumbles under breath about OP's uncle's teacher not knowing about recessive genetics*
 
[ - ]  heatherrawrieeGood: 4Bad: 12 years ago
God. It's all about the alleles. Science teachers know nothing these days!
 
[ - ]  GortehGood: 7Bad: 02 years ago
Pretty much, they probably learn what they teach from yahoo answers.
 
[ - ]  alleeiscoolGood: 6Bad: 12 years ago
ya, and if they would've looked on google then they would have the right answer :)
 
[ - ]  reallyquiteaverageGood: 14Bad: 02 years ago
teacher fail.
 
[ - ]  ha1eemGood: 16Bad: 02 years ago
uhm recessive alleles, duh. teacher should know better?
 
[ - ]  goldenbraceletGood: 18Bad: 02 years ago
It would, however, be extremely unlikely for two blue-eyed parents to have a brown-eyed baby. Perhaps the OP simply got confused?
 
[ - ]  TheRedBirdGood: 7Bad: 02 years ago
That would be the kind assumption. But, as you can see, most of the commenters on this site are not kind people.
 
[ - ]  uncreativeGood: 1Bad: 02 years ago
Yes, I am more inclined to assume the OP messed up than that the teacher did. But even so, it is possible for two blue-eyed parents to have a brown-eyed child, just very unlikely. This is the problem with the simplified teaching of genetics, the few exceptions get concerned that they aren't related to their parents when they are. Of course, we have only fairly recently learned about genetic chimericism. (I may be spelling that wrong.)
 
[ - ]  deppfan85Good: 0Bad: 22 years ago
Actually, that is impossible. Since blue eyes are recessive, only the recessive gene can be passed on.
 
[ - ]  ExerciGood: 0Bad: 02 years ago
Sorry bro, high school genetics don't exactly teach it indepth enough. "The entire Dominant/recessive (And this is the only relevant factor)" starts wearing off when you do some more genetic work.
 
Maybe they got the colors backwards? Would that work? I haven't had bio in forever so i'm not totally sure...
 
[ - ]  averagekittehGood: 5Bad: 32 years ago
yeah, blue-eyed parents can only have blue-eyed children b/c its a recessive gene
 
[ - ]  ftlogGood: 35Bad: 02 years ago
For the love of all things mendel, someone get this man a science textbook.
 
[ - ]  whatsgoingon459Good: 4Bad: 02 years ago
Hehe :D That's great.
 
[ - ]  butifulghurlGood: 1Bad: 02 years ago
wow... Stupid teacher...
 
[ - ]  McgriffinGood: 4Bad: 12 years ago
Its the other way round. Two blue eyed parents can't have a brown eyed baby... fail
 
[ - ]  dukky93Good: 2Bad: 02 years ago
well I was gonna post about how the op must have their colors confused, but you guys beat me to it. . .
 
[ - ]  hldcrstnGood: 3Bad: 02 years ago
couldnt you have a recessive gene....
 
[ - ]  PrincessTangoGood: 0Bad: 122 years ago
thts not true bcoz the girl could have gotten her blue eyes even if her parents had brown eyes bcoz maybe someone else in the family had blue eyes
 
[ - ]  PrincessTangoGood: 4Bad: 172 years ago
the whole world is related bcoz everybodys ancesters are Adam and Eve so the world is family i belive this theory( ofcourse i would i made it up,but it makes sense)but i dont get y there r ppl of differnent colours like brown and white etc.
 
[ - ]  guardgirl2011Good: 14Bad: 12 years ago
Do you not know proper English? I can't understand half of what you are saying! trnzltion: do u not no english? i dnt undrstnd hlf of wut u r saying!
 
[ - ]  Alice_PaigeGood: 2Bad: 12 years ago
Not true the parents both had the one recessive gene and one dominate the girl inherited the recessive gene from both
 
[ - ]  thefailingmonsterGood: 4Bad: 02 years ago
FAIL
 
[ - ]  RavenclawGirlGood: 2Bad: 02 years ago
How did this ever get posted? Basic genetics, people... The allele for brown eyes is dominant to the one of blue eyes. So the parents could both have a recessive allele for blue eyes and one for brown eyes, making their phenotype brown eyes, but their genotype heterozygous.
 
[ - ]  CouryMFGGood: 8Bad: 02 years ago
Hopefully a color mix up in posting, otherwise gahh. Also, you guys are mostly right on the other side of things. Goldenbracelet was right with the statement that it's very unlikely for blue-eyed parents to have a brown-eyed child. It is *not* however, impossible. Blue-eyed parents can have brown-eyed children because genetics forming eye color are not as simple has having one allele dominant over the other and do not fit the rules for basic Mendelian inheritance.. Color expression is due to multiple copies of the alleles that produce the pigments brown and yellow and that exhibit different levels of penetrance. Blue eyes can be caused by low pigment levels or a defective or mutated gene for the expression of pigments. Likewise, brown eyes can occur this way. Blue-eyed parents can have green- or brown-eyed children naturally. Phew.
 
[ - ]  MusikGood: 4Bad: 02 years ago
I'm in middle school and I know that... Gosh. You learn it in 6th-7th grade. Dumbass
 
[ - ]  CottsGood: 2Bad: 02 years ago
This was the exact lesson I had today in biology. If both parents carry the blue eyed gene the baby can have blue eyes. Lucky, since both my parents have brown eyes and mine are blue.
 
[ - ]  orangepoolwaterGood: 2Bad: 02 years ago
I love how everyone knows this about eye colors.
 
[ - ]  andrea87Good: 1Bad: 02 years ago
thats not true becasue blue eyes are a recessive gene so if two parents have the dominant gene Brown and the recessive gene blue then their child can have clue eyes. My sister has blue eyes and my parents both have brown eyes.
 
[ - ]  andrea87Good: 0Bad: 02 years ago
**i mean blue not clue
 
[ - ]  lapianomusaGood: 0Bad: 02 years ago
that's totally incorrect. brown is dominate, blue is recessive. if both of the parents had the brown/blue genotype then they could have a blue eyed kid. simple biology. idiot, get your facts right.
 
[ - ]  samchalekGood: 0Bad: 32 years ago
Uh huh...I know I'm not the first to say this, but it's actually the other way around. Blue eyes are a recessive gene, so if both parents carry the gene they can have a blue-eyed baby. Brown eyes are dominant, so if the parent has genes for both colors, their eyes will be brown. On the other hand, left-handedness is recessive, and my brother and I are right-handed whereas our parents are both left-handed. Which is impossible. We're freaks, I guess
 
[ - ]  JessinGood: 1Bad: 02 years ago
Being left or right handed does not run in the genes.
 
[ - ]  BewussteinslageGood: 0Bad: 12 years ago
It does, actually. As a side note, something like 80% of left-handed people had/have a twin, even if their mother doesn't know it (disappearing twin syndrome-one egg swallows the other).
 
[ - ]  biochemGood: 1Bad: 02 years ago
That's creepy.
 
[ - ]  gneissisniceGood: 0Bad: 02 years ago
Man, do they just hire anyone as science teachers these days? Blue is recessive, brown is dominant. Two brown eyed parents that have a genotype of Bb have a chance of having a blue eyed child (yes I know eye color is a little more complicated than that, but it still works out like that anyway).
 
[ - ]  JessinGood: 0Bad: 02 years ago
Gutted I was slow on the sciencey bit.
 
It's called recessive genes.
 
[ - ]  whosoeverGood: 0Bad: 02 years ago
someone in my bio class found out he was adopted after the teacher explained the genetics of blood types. he happened to know his and his parent`s blood type, which were incompatible. :P
 
[ - ]  TsukikoSuohGood: 2Bad: 02 years ago
that's a lie! it's just a recessive gene, both my younger brother and I have blue eyes and blond hair. Our parents are brunettes with brown and hazel eyes.
 
[ - ]  whosoeverGood: 1Bad: 02 years ago
yeah, but it is uncommon. there is at most a one quarter chance for two brown eyed parents have a blue eyed child
 
[ - ]  uncreativeGood: 0Bad: 12 years ago
That doesn't make it that uncommon. Especially in a larger family. I have 4 siblings whom I share hoth of my parents with. It would not have been surprising if one of us had had blue eyes had both of my parents had brown eyes.
 
[ - ]  latingeekGood: 3Bad: 42 years ago
all babies are born with blue eyes.
 
[ - ]  BewussteinslageGood: 1Bad: 32 years ago
EPIC FAIL.
 
[ - ]  Poxleitner17Good: 1Bad: 02 years ago
LMFAO YOU JUST MADE MY DAY. wait, is that bad?
 
[ - ]  LissaRayGood: 2Bad: 22 years ago
Umm. Its two blue-eyed parents can't have a brown eyed child...
 
[ - ]  tomahtoGood: 2Bad: 02 years ago
actually, eye color is made up of many genes for the single trait, and however many dominant to recessive combo is your eye color, i.e NNoo is violet :) just finished that unit in science
 
[ - ]  RussianKatyaGood: 1Bad: 02 years ago
actually,it's possibly. 25% chance of a blue eyed kid it depends on the parents genes
 
[ - ]  biochemGood: 1Bad: 02 years ago
Yeah. I won't go all redundant - but, wow, we're supposed to be average. C's are average, and yet we all sound smart. lol just kidding. I get straight 97s and better.
 
[ - ]  histnerdGood: 0Bad: 02 years ago
I have blue eyes, both of my parents and my siblings have brown eyes. The link? My grandfather's eyes are the exact same shade of blue as mine. It's possible, just rare.
 
[ - ]  greenweed14Good: 0Bad: 02 years ago
there not rare, pay attention to genetics. damn.
 
[ - ]  greenweed14Good: 0Bad: 02 years ago
WOW OP fail, its possible for to herozygous brown eyed parents to have a blue eyed child, it is impossible for two blue eyed parents to have a brown eyed child seeing as how the trait for blue eyes is a double recessive.
 
[ - ]  DiatainGood: 0Bad: 02 years ago
My parent have brown eyes, same with my siblings. i have blue. im the black sheep. im also left handed everyone else is right handed...
 
[ - ]  humanespressoGood: 0Bad: 02 years ago
There's a local African-American family whose daughters all come to my art center. The first three have milk-chocolate skin, black hair and dark brown eyes. The youngest has mocha skin, blue eyes, and BLONDE HAIR. And yes, all four girls have the same parents. How's THAT for recessive genetics?
 
[ - ]  NewtokeoGood: 0Bad: 02 years ago
Haha!!! What a stupid thing to say!:) blue is a reccesive gene... Two heterosygous brown eyes could... And have a 1 in 4 chance of havin a blue baby
 

Sign in/Register to comment.

Official links

the official MLIA blog

the MLIA store

We did it! We sponsored a well

RSS Feed | Contact Us | Privacy and Terms of Use
Copyright 2009-2010 Corniche. MyLifeIsAverage, MLIA and the MyLifeIsAverage logo are trademark of Corniche. Developed by nomadlabs