Harry Potter is the worst book ever. Twilight is at least something good to read. But harry potter? he makes me want to be sick, I hate him with a passion.
Do you want to make some fast easy money, even while you read MLIA? On factoidz.com, you make a modest 1-5 cent(s) per view, but as you get 100s of views on each of your simple 400 word articles, it can quickly add up to years of easy cash. Skip immediately to level 2 (factoidz writer) by signing up with this link (and i'll help get web traffic to your articles because I get 5% of what you make with no penalty to you). Trustworthy and pays through PayPal.
http://factoidz.com/earn-revenue-now/6A14076
DISSAGREE! DO YOU KNOW THAT NEW MOON MADE LIKE 100000000000000000000000000000000000000000 BUCKS?! i hate avatar! but still i'd rather be a werewolf loving Jacob rather then Edward...the pale 'person' who wants 2 kill me.
i haven't read either but Harry potter sounds like a better read; a bit more complex which i like. but i agree with you. forts and hot chocolate tromp all.
how sad is it that when someone tries to compromise, they all shut it down? sad, sad, world. I noticed that it became this way when the first hp movie came out. haha.
Twilight fans aren't dribbling, psycho HP haters. We're actually Average and witty and educated too.
And fyi, I clicked average, And I'm a Twilight fan, just because of this comment. I feel like a rebel.
I agree. And i think i know why this is: its easier to make a fool of yourself (and have fun doing it!)by relating Harry Potter to an everyday situation than Twilight. Aside from trashy romance between a sparkly vampire and some random teenage girl theres nothing extreme about twilight that would be fun to do in public.
This is definately true!! I really like both but it's far easier and more fun to make a tool of yourself in public with HP I think that's mainly cos it has such a big fanbase and there is nothing else like it so many people can relate and join in whereas Twilight is just another Vampire tale with a slight twist here or there.
I still really like both though haha so don't hate me, please!
Exactly. (: Haha. Which is why I hope and think that Twilight will have almost zero cultural impact, unlike how Harry Potter has had such a huge cultural impact on the world.
Daniel Radcliffe isn't ugly either.
But, anyway, at least Harry Potter isn't just about how attractive a guy is. *cough cough* like Twilight is *cough cough*
(((I've already commented on about a million things on this page... why not make it a million and one?))
Amandagail1995--- I don't see how you can call anyone ignorant. three times you have decided that someone should die simply because they have a different opinion than you on this one little thing, without knowing anything else about them. I don't know about anyone else, but I would say that's pretty darn ignorant.
I really don't see how someone is illiterate just because they don't like HP. Maybe fantasy books just aren't what they're into.
And wouldnt Harry be average, and thats why average people are into him? If he was ugly, it'd be the FML community, since they're all about the negative. =]
YumiChan or whtever your name is, cool it. Everyone here should take that advice. Books are books, nothing more. They're certainly no reason to want to kill anyone.
I love you. :)
Hmm I find it funny, the vampire which you seem to hate was in one of you harry potter films, who ever picked robert pattinson had taste. Twilight is aimed at teenage girls who find the need to satisfy there lonely hearts by reading romantic mush with no real plot.
dude, twilight came AFTER the fourth harry potter movie, and WE weren't the ones whose put him in the twilight movie. So, therefore, you cannot chastise us because robert pattinson was in both movies.
I must say, I have a slight argument to put in place here- in addition to Rupert, Freddie Stroma and Tom Felton make Robert Pattinson look like, well, some ugly old fart, really.
I bet he washed his hair when he played Cedric Diggory because Harry Potter inspired him to have personal hygiene and Twilight inspired him to be disgusting.
HP ftw? I'm sorry, but hardcore rabid twilight fans are scary. They used to be In the Closet. Then their obsession became tangible with Rob Pattinson and that is why he's terrified of his fans.
neither j.k. rowling nor stephenie meyer can write that well. but i would haveto say Meyer is the lesser of the two. she uses the same adjectives for everything. and without the presence of sex and attractive situations in her books they would be noowhere near as popular. jk rowling has a wonderful imagination and most of te spells and names in her books are based on latin words which i think is cool. and she has more complex characters/development and a far better thought out plot. although im sorry to say the twighlight books do have their appeal.
Wow guys, Twilight isn't awful. And hating on Twilight won't make Harry Potter look cool. It make's people look like immature little fan-girl snobs. Patronus to that!
Sorry but i have to disagree with you....Twilight IS really bad. Oh and just to let you know most of those "immature fangirl snobs" belong to Twilight.
Wow...harsh? Agreed, it's not the best piece of literature out there, but that's a bit extreme, no?
Please don't kill me for that, I'm just saying that it seemed a little...overly-mean
I'm a fan of both, because I like the writing in Twilight (don't kill me!) but then this huge teenybopper popculture fandom came along when the movie was coming out. I was really mad that my love for it was now considered immature.
But Harry Potter still owns Twilight any day! JK Rowling IS a better writer than Stephenie Meyer, she fits satire in perfectly.
not liking twilight doesn't mean we are ruining it,
considering that no one ever talks about twilight here anyways. we're ruining MLIA by everyone fighting about it.
Thank you! I love Twilight and Harry Potter. But rally, Rupert Grint?!??!?!? Ew! I don't like Robert Pattinson, but he's amazing compared to Rupert Grint!!
Can I just take the time to say that no one should really be comparing Harry Potter to Twilight at all? I mean, honestly...they are about two different things, were written for two different reasons, and one is clearly better written. So comparing apples to oranges is just silly.
Of course, I agree that it is great that the average person has better taste! ;D
Yes!!! I totally agree. You can't even compare Twiligt and Harry Potter - they are just too different. And I'm not saying one is better than the other, I'm saying they're for different crowds, different genres, etc. Twilight is a love story, Harry Potter is about 'magic'. So, people, get a grip, grow up, or go away.
i dont know why people thumbs you down lol but yea there shouldnt be fighting in mlia!!! in a average life you dont fight with people you guys!! everyone has different taste thats all i got to say. (i personally dont like twilight to me its just another movie) im just putting it out there :p haha. but no seriously :/
I agree with the OP, but now people are started to argue with each other and saying "I hope you die" to people who don't like Harry Potter.
Where did all the love go?
I love you for saying that.
I love harry potter just as much as the next average person, but let's not shun others for having different opinions, please!
I love you all for saying this. I think arguing for like a second, then agreeing that it's okay to disagree is okay, but hoping others DIE? I like Twilight AND Harry Potter (Harry Potter over Twilight, though- no question in my mind, I am obsessed with Harry Potter, Twilight is just a series I've read) and I think the fighting is a little rude.
Robsessed47, did you seriously just say "ome?"
Please, do us all a favor and go die.
I read and love both series(but HP>Twilight), but thats just ridiculously stupid.
How old are you, 12?
back to witches and wizards and magical beasts to goblins and ghosts and to magical feasts its all that i love and its all that i need at hogwarts hogwarts :) That musical is so totally awesome :)
OMG SQUEEELLLLL THIS MLIA SAID TWILIGHTT!!!!! EDDWAARDDDDD!!!!!!!!!!!
...cough. haha (kidding.)
i did like twilight before the teenyboppers got to it, but now it's kinda overrated. still, HP always was and always will be first in my heart. lol =]
isn't telling people to go die over book preferences a bit extreme? i thought the mlia community was about loving each other in all of our averageness.
Uh... why does it matter? The two series really don't have much in common, so why is there such a big issue with it? I think I know, because people are idiots.
Because they're on opposite ends of the literary spectrum. On the one hand, you have an epic tale with a huge cast of deep, relatable individuals that experience everything from prejudice and a battle between good and evil, to typical high school shenanigans and funny spells gone awry. And it all takes place in a world that supposedly exists along side our own, and easy to fantasize yourself into, creating a wonderful blend of perfectly executed literature and slightly unhealthy escapism. It's characters have very real personalities, with everything from the brave boy who can withstand tragedy and adversity, and still come out a good person, to the not-so-brave boy who is a relic of older visionaries like Crime and Punishment and The Jungle in construction, who although the antagonist and the representative of evil, still contains character and give a fair fight of not only 'power', but clashing personalities too, that gives readers the type of satisfaction that can only be brought by such aptly portrayed clash.
On the other hand, you have a bland book written by an obviously self-centered and untrained author who is basically full-filling all her broken dreams by writing down her fantasies, using liberal purple prose so we know EXACTLY how good-looking her dream man is. The plot is nonexistent, the main character is portrayed with the formula to ensnare the emotional reader to experience all the wonderful things happening to her, and most importantly to celebrate her mediocrity as if she deserved everything in the world, despite never proving herself an exceptional person in the least. It was poorly written from an intellectual point of view, and expertly written from a pop culture point of view: sappy, in other words.
Those who feel both are good are in the middle of the spectrum, and from there point of view, almost everything is good, so long as it's finished, has at least one endearing character, and doesn't have run-on sentences.
In other words, average.
Congratulations!
HP is better then Twilight, but i still like it a bit. I think that is someone with better Talent wrote it and changed it but still kept the base story, twlight would be better
Haha that's what I thought too. I kind of wanted to rewrite it for her; make the characters more likable and give the books more plot than "Bella looked into Edward's eyes blah blah blah blah"
Perhaps, I mean it is finally back in the public's notice again, but, for a lot of us, the obsession isn't really heightened by movies coming out...I'm always this way :)
I agree with Aclynnb88. I love the books more than words can describe, to be cheesily honest. I don't even care about the movies, but when they come out I am pushed back into the mentality of 'Harry Potter needs your attention!' so I read the series again. I'm on the 5th one now, for about the 7th or 8th time ever. :D
That was a very brave thing for you to post.
And definitley the one i'll ever agree with the most.
Twilight fails, and just because somebody doesn't like a certain book doesn't make them an "illiterate arse" as Yumi-Chan chose to put it; it makes somebody with an honest opinon, and theres nothing wrong with that...
Anyways. My HONEST opinion is that I did give Twilight a go, and I just couldn't get into it the same way i could get into the Harry Potter books, I think it's really unimaginative, and very VERY dull.
P.S
The film is just as bad - if not - worse.
P.P.S
Robert Patterson is hideous.
I agree completely. I read the Twilight books, but they honestly bored the hell out of me. By the second and third books, I totally hated all the characters.
HP on the other hand is pure genius writing in so many ways!
Although I don't think Robert PattINson is hideous.. he looks good onscreen, but can't seem to take a good picture to save his life.
I agree with you two. I read the Twilight Books, and I did not like them at all. I think the problem with Twilight is that the fangirls scare the crap out of me. At least most Harry Potter fans are mature because the books came out when they were younger, and they have grown up.
Harry Potter Is Very Awsum, Buht Why DO You Have To Trash Twilight Honestly, It Doesnt Make Any Sence. I Bet Half The People Who Hate Twilight Never Even Gave It A Chance. And For Those People Who Did Must Of Only Read The First Chapter Which I Admit Is Dull Buht After That Its Excellent. Buht I Really Hate Posts Like This Because MLIA Was Better Than This, Favoring Books For Stupid Reasond, Like Trashing Another Book. I Love Twilight Its Fantastic, Buht I Also Love Harry Potter {Im Re-Reading The Books ^^} -sigh- I Really Thought This Site Was Loving, Buht I Was Obviously Wrong.
This MLIA is one person's opinion, not the whole site's. Also, nice use of the shift key. Must've taken you an extra five minutes just to capatalize every word. *high fives*
Maybe now you can understand what it's like to be someone who dislikes the series that everyone is paying attention to. I swear, for months I couldn't go into a mall without seeing 50 stores with Twilight merch in it, and I couldn't walk down the halls of my school without seeing giggly girls sporting "Team Edward" paraphernalia. It was sickening! So now Harry Potter is the big thing, and it just irks you to see Twilight pushed aside for the series that was here first!
now, I can't say I think that J.K.Rowling is a good author, because I don't think that is the case. She is an alright author, I suppose, but I like the story more than the writing. And I started reading Twilight and I don't think that Stephanie Meyer is much of a writer either.
and one last thing: please find a dictionary and consult it next time you're going to write something that other people will see. Buht is not a word.
..."buht"? Note: capitalizing every word and deliberately mispelling words does not look cool. Twilight sucks. I read the entire series. It really, really sucks,
Everything is about vampires these days!!! It STINKS!!!! And especially when they make vampires ROMANTIC? What is wrong with those people? I think people just like twilight because it's 'cooler' then harry potter right now for the teenage girls. Harry Potter IS THE BEST!!!
GUYS! We need to stop fighting:( We have to keep the peace and not let MLIA turn into FML, with all the negative comments and fighting and what not... I love you.
Well, I was about to defend Twilight (not in "u suck, twilight rules! RP is hawtttttt!1!" kinda way, but in a mature normal way) when my internet crashed. I learned my lesson and will content myself with sharing this fun story that no one cares about, but I'm bored and trying to look like I'm working.
So I liked Twilight before it became a fad (right, everyone says that), but I straight up lie when people ask me if I like it now because I fear being labeled a crazy fan. Seriously, I like the series and I judge the fans of it. But, by the same token, I judge Harry Potter fans. Not the ones who have bonding moments with strangers, but the ones who dressed up and proceeded to act like they WERE the characters from the series. And the same ones who pushed me down at the release of the seventh book and then got angry because I got pulled to the front of the line by the staff of the bookstore who felt bad for me.
Hm, lost sight of where I was going with this...I guess we should take it as a sign that MLIA has yet to be overrun with immature, weirdoes who think that liking an okay fictional character equates to love for the actor who portrays (rather poorly, I might add) this character in a crappy-ass movie.
(Sorry, go ahead and hide this comment, just wanted toss in my opinion.)
great comment, made me laugh.
And I agree, although I never got trampled by crazed fans and moved to the front of the line in pity. I like Harry Potter; and truthfully, I like Twilight too. Somehow, the plot intrigued me. But I don't so much enjoy classifying myself with a lot of the crazy hard core fans of either one.
[In the light of full disclosure, I am also slightly ashamed to say that I watch disney channel. another instance in which I don't want to tell people the truth, simply because I don't want them to judge me based on most of the people who watch it.]
I KNow that Harry Potter Was Here First. Im Not Saying Its Bad I Love Harry Potter Is Super Ahhmazing ^^ Buht Twilight Is Really Good Too. {I Kno That 'Buht' Isnt A Word I Just Like To Use It, Im A Teemager Thats What I Do} I Hate Twilights popularity Becuase Now Theres A Bunch Of Wanna Be Fans Who Think They Know Twilight Just By Watching The Movie. Thats What Maks People Hate Twilight, I Almost Hate It Buht I Dont Because I Can Honeslty Say I Liked It Before It Was Popular And I Read All The Books. Buht Im Not A Crazed Fan Who Obsesess Over It, I Dont Even Talk About It Much Unless Im With My Friends. So There Is Really No Reason To Trash Twilight On MLIA, Just Because Of Crazed Wanna Be Twilight Fans Who Love Robert Pattinson {He Was Okay In Harry Potter Buht He Makes A Terrible Edward}
You know, every word doesn't have to be capitalized. I'm sure you're very proud of the fact that you're a 'Teemager', but being 13 doesn't mean it's okay to ignore grammar. Apparently it just makes you cool.
cause harry potter fans lives are average. Twilight fans have great lives.
and we're losers for wishing Edwards real? you guys go around saying spells..um WTF? Everyones moved on from harry potter. Get over it.
GASP!!! I LOVE TWILIGHT!!!! if it's alll on FML maybe i'll go over to the dark side... oh wait that's star wars... (right?) fine well im going over the TREATY LINE then. HA! that's twilight. you better watch it or ill provoke the Volturi and blame you... grrr (vicious vampire snarl)
This is the kind of Twilight fan that gives all of them a bad name.
I think they're both good, by the way. I think I like HP a bit better, but Twilight's still alright. I don't see all the craze over it, though. That part doesn't make sense to me.
Mechelleee: only a real fan would say that... hmm im on to you... and if real men dont sparkle... then real men TURN INTO GIANT HORSE SIZED WOLVES ON COMMAND!!!! (in other words Emmett is married so i want Seth
I Can Ignore Grammer All I Want It Really Dosnt Matter On This Website. Nd The 'n' and The 'm' Are rite Next Tew Each Other So Its Kinda Obvious That I Ment Tew Type Teenager {Duh}. You Dont Need To Criticize, How I Write/Type Sheeesh. What Happeneed To All The Love?
I can honestly say that I liked Twilight before the "teenyboppers" came around also, I haven't seen the movies and I straight up refuse to (I like to hide the fact I read them as well)... After seeing all of these comments I started to think about how much more I love Harry Potter than any other series of ever read. I would stay up until 4 Am just to get to that next chapter even though I knew I needed to go to sleep. I would have dreams about Harry Potter that made me happy even if they were scary cause I got to be apart of that world =D
I'm not one of the crazy fans that dresses up by any means, but I do enjoy reading these awesome average occurrences day-to-day and I will say that Harry Potter beats Twilight all the way!!
Just useless story telling to get my point across =D
i guess im not as average as i thought
i can love both harry potter and twilight and not have to critize everyone for only loving one.
come on people this isnt FML why is everyone being so rude?
ok ...um Harry Potter is about some dumass wizards or watever and Twilight is about romance and life. OK SO DO I WANA WATCH A MOVIE ABOUT SUM WIZARD FAGS OR SEXY VAMPIRES? IM GUNA GO WITH THE VAMPIRES. u guys need 2 shut the hell up and realize that harry potter is soooooo LAST YEAR! u can cuss me out all u want but just remember dont play games with a girl who can play them better
I beg to differ. Harry Potter is about /smart/ wizards and the bonds of friendship and magic. It even has twists of reality that allow the readers to relate.
Twilight is real life getting punched in the face by oddly formed vampires and werewolves. Meyer could've at least given said species a chance by making them what they're supposed to have been, not pale glittering leeches and horse-sized dogs. Also, the plot is practically nonexistant.
And by the way, I just so happened to read all of the Twilight books. Meyer should've just stopped at two.
Game on, sister.
I'm a girl. I don't think the game you're talking about is even existing. And I know how to spell "dumbass" and "want to" instead of wana. At least say wanna. >_>
ok ...um Harry Potter is about some dumass wizards or watever and Twilight is about romance and life. OK SO DO I WANA WATCH A MOVIE ABOUT SUM WIZARD FAGS OR SEXY VAMPIRES? IM GUNA GO WITH THE VAMPIRES. u guys need 2 shut the hell up and realize that harry potter is soooooo LAST YEAR! u can cuss me out all u want but just remember dont play games with a girl who can play them better
ok ...um Harry Potter is about some dumass wizards or watever and Twilight is about romance and life. OK SO DO I WANA WATCH A MOVIE ABOUT SUM WIZARD FAGS OR SEXY VAMPIRES? IM GUNA GO WITH THE VAMPIRES. u guys need 2 shut the hell up and realize that harry potter is soooooo LAST YEAR! u can cuss me out all u want but just remember dont play games with a girl who can play them better
I'm going to be average and say... HP ftw. I used to like Twilight... until I reread it and actually absorbed it... especially when I saw Head Trip by Shinga on deviantart. She even has a chapter-by-chapter parody of the first book... somewhere...
Th 'average' person doesn't go on MLIA. And why can't anyone seem to se that you can like Harry Potter AND Twilight? Because I do. And I know a lot of people who would agree. So all you haters of either series, get a grip. :)
twilight is good. the whole series. i just want to say that, cuz some people don't thinks so. hp is a different style of writing, and i like it too, for different reasons. so ya. being average is not choosing a favorite. so there.
I love the Twilight series, I'm not a preteen, I don't plan on marrying Robert Pattinson, and I'm not a dribbling psycho fangirl either. And to be honest, I think that guy from the Harry Potter movies is kind of unnattractive. (Don't go homicidal on me for saying that). But I continue to find all of the MLIA's funny as hell, and I just love the whitty averageness of everyone here! See, Twilight fans and HP fans can get along.
OMG!!!!!
You dont know how long i've been waiting for someone to write that Harry Potter is better than twilight. I've loved HP sice i was like......5 or 6!!! THE LAST BOOK IS THE BEST
LONG LIVE HARRY POTTER
I find that Twilight is a good book. Sure it isn't the best book I've ever read though it was still pretty good. The movie was nothing compared to the book and they even added in fake scences when they could have just gone by the book. If you people don't like Twilight that's not my problem though I don't want you telling me the book sucked.
I happen to love Twilight.
I think this is very rude to all the
fans of it and I don't appericiate it.
Sorry.
GO TWILIGHT!
*Besides, Harry Potter is full of douche bags. :)
Twilight was a poorly written series that had no plot, was full of holes, had flat characters, and was a literary abomination. Harry Potter isn't "full of douche bags", as you put it. So, HP wins.
umm u r one of the biggest hypocrites ever! u say we r mean but then u were mean!!!!! think about it! and harry potter is twice the man edward will evr be no matter how hard edward tries to be cool
I have been a fan of Harry Potter for years. I read Twilight just to see what all the fuss was about. The first book was okay until the sparkling. The last book seemed like fanfiction of fanfiction.I am a huge fan of vampires and I read vampire books all the time. Twilight is such a disgrace to the vampire genre. Harry Potter is better written, has a more interesting plot, and is just made of win all around.
I don't have anything against Harry Potter, but I'm a little sick of the Harry Potter posts. They were funny the first couple of times, but now it's just getting old.
This MLIA is wonderful.
I had a tattoo of a little red apple on my ankle because I was very proud of living in NYC ("the big apple") and got approached at least once a week by some Twilight fangirl practically squealing herself into a literature-coma and asking if the ink was done for Twilight and would then talk my ear off about some sparkly-vampire (aka horrific) plotline that I knew nothing about. After finally getting curious enough about what all the excitement was about, I finally picked up the books for myself and read them. Within the next week I got my apple tattoo covered up because I never wanted to associate anything permanently on my skin with that mediocre series. Just thought I'd share my story. Don't get me wrong, the books are "OK" (at most) but definitely not tattoo worthy. I still can't believe it cost me that much pain/trouble to avoid further Robert Pattinson squealage. Now HP, on the other hand, is definitely awesome enough to stop and chat about on the street with random strangers.
I'm proud to say that HP has been my drug of choice since 1992 and all other fans/readers just have a little something extra about them to enjoy. Hopefully you all know what I mean. You guys = love.
Don't get me wrong. I love HP too, actually i'm totally obsessed with reading and writing fanfics about it among other things but how has HP been your drug of choice since 1992 when it was first published in 1997?
This MLIA is wonderful.
I had a tattoo of a little red apple on my ankle because I was very proud of living in NYC ("the big apple") and got approached at least once a week by some Twilight fangirl practically squealing herself into a literature-coma and asking if the ink was done for Twilight and would then talk my ear off about some sparkly-vampire (aka horrific) plotline that I knew nothing about. After finally getting curious enough about what all the excitement was about, I finally picked up the books for myself and read them. Within the next week I got my apple tattoo covered up because I never wanted to associate anything permanently on my skin with that mediocre series. Just thought I'd share my story. Don't get me wrong, the books are "OK" (at most) but definitely not tattoo worthy. I still can't believe it cost me that much pain/trouble to avoid further Robert Pattinson squealage. Now HP, on the other hand, is definitely awesome enough to stop and chat about on the street with random strangers.
I'm proud to say that HP has been my drug of choice since 1992 and all other fans/readers just have a little something extra about them to enjoy. Hopefully you all know what I mean. You guys = love.
This MLIA is wonderful.
I had a tattoo of a little red apple on my ankle because I was very proud of living in NYC ("the big apple") and got approached at least once a week by some Twilight fangirl practically squealing herself into a literature-coma and asking if the ink was done for Twilight and would then talk my ear off about some sparkly-vampire (aka horrific) plotline that I knew nothing about. After finally getting curious enough about what all the excitement was about, I finally picked up the books for myself and read them. Within the next week I got my apple tattoo covered up because I never wanted to associate anything permanently on my skin with that mediocre series. Just thought I'd share my story. Don't get me wrong, the books are "OK" (at most) but definitely not tattoo worthy. I still can't believe it cost me that much pain/trouble to avoid further Robert Pattinson squealage. Now HP, on the other hand, is definitely awesome enough to stop and chat about on the street with random strangers.
I'm proud to say that HP has been my drug of choice since 1992 and all other fans/readers just have a little something extra about them to enjoy. Hopefully you all know what I mean. You guys = love.
This MLIA is wonderful.
I had a tattoo of a little red apple on my ankle because I was very proud of living in NYC ("the big apple") and got approached at least once a week by some Twilight fangirl practically squealing herself into a literature-coma and asking if the ink was done for Twilight and would then talk my ear off about some sparkly-vampire (aka horrific) plotline that I knew nothing about. After finally getting curious enough about what all the excitement was about, I finally picked up the books for myself and read them. Within the next week I got my apple tattoo covered up because I never wanted to associate anything permanently on my skin with that mediocre series. Just thought I'd share my story. Don't get me wrong, the books are "OK" (at most) but definitely not tattoo worthy. I still can't believe it cost me that much pain/trouble to avoid further Robert Pattinson squealage. Now HP, on the other hand, is definitely awesome enough to stop and chat about on the street with random strangers.
I'm proud to say that HP has been my drug of choice since 1992 and all other fans/readers just have a little something extra about them to enjoy. Hopefully you all know what I mean. You guys = love.
I Happen to love Both series. these books have nothing in common there for they should not be juged together. Each book has a diffrent aspect that Each reader my find intresting at a diffrent point. It does not make theses series any less captivating.
Twilight was AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!! (well...the book was atleast...the movie was eh) and I can't wait for New Moon!!!!!!!! (the book was ohawesome and i hope the movie is) =)))))))
i used to love twilight (the book) until the crappy movie came out and ruined everything no everyone loves twilight and most of them dont even know it was originaly a book! its so annoying..
I see no point in insulting a Twilight fan or a Harry Potter fan.
I've been in love with both series for a while now and I'm not some rabid fangirl of either.
Both series have their downfalls and both have their stereotypical fans that ruin it for everyone else.
No one deserves death wishes because of this.
Cedric Diggory > Edward Cullen
Harry Potter > Edward Cullen
Ron Weasely > Jasper Cullen
Hermoine Granger > Alice Cullen
Ginny Weasely > Bella Swan
Hogwarts > Forks, Washington
Harry Potter > Twilight
Cedric Diggory < Edward Cullen
Harry Potter < Edward Cullen
Ron Weasely < Jasper Cullen
Hermoine Granger < Alice Cullen
Ginny Weasely < Bella Swan
Hogwarts < Forks, Washington
Harry Potter < Twilight
Dear everyone.
harry potter fucking sucks,get on with your shamless lives
and go watch twilight :D cause twilight fucking pwns harry potters ass ;) and you all know it.if you didnt, YOU DO NOW BITCHZZZZZZZZ
After reading a few of these posts, I get the feeling that all Harry Potter fans are asses. Why do you hate Twilight so much? I bet half of you never even read Harry Potter or Twilight. And I don't see how you can "hate twilight with a burning rage". That pisses me off. If you really did, you would have burned all of the Twilight books you could get your hands on. And stop saying that you hate Twilight because everyone else says so.
The world ruined twilight for the rest of us. Robert pattinson is SOOOOO NOT hot enough to ever even stand close to Edward. True twilight fans read the books before the movies came out. I'm now ashamed to call myself a twilight fan because of the CRAP the world has soiled it with.
As stated by someone else above...Twilight and HP are two totally different types of books. Can someone not like both of them?? Yes...the twilight MOVIE sucked...they didn't have the money it takes to make a fabulous movie...hopefully New Moon will be better. I do love the Twilight saga books...but also i am not obsessed...and i do like the HP movies...again...definately NOT obsessed...the end!
i like twilight and harry potter, but i am not a ginormous fan for either of them.
dont be mad at me or hate me, but.....twilight is better....
love you all!
i think this is the stupidest thing ever i hope you realize that twilight is sooooooo much better then gay potter
AND BTW THE REASON REAL MEN DONT SPARKLE IS BECAUSE EDWARD CULLEN IS THE ONLY REAL MAN I DONT SEE ANY OTHER GUYS CARRYING ME UP TREEES!!!!!!!!!! IN YOUR FACE!
Harry Potter AND Twilight both suck ass. I'm a 14-yr-old girl and I can't stand them. They're over read, over played, over done, and they have sucky plots, and are written terribly. The acting sucks in all of them, but Kristin Stewart is literally the worst actress I have ever even seen. You're wrong, OP, the average person would think Harry Potter is for losers and nerds, and the average person would think the same thing of Twilight. Suck it up, and get some fucking friends.
im glad we have the same prespective
every few days ill hear the word sparkle or vampire and i shout VAMPIRES DONT SPARKLE THEY OBLIDERATE IN SUNLIGHT fangirls get pissed at me. i argue for like 15 minutes with like 2 at a time until i finally come up with a resolution. team jacob or team edward. one day both girls said team jacob... i was like ok so vamps dont sparkle end of story. they stared at me blankly... O.o
ok so i like both harry potter and twilight. and yes harry potter is amazing, but if you haven't read twilight (because yeah, the movie wasnt that good) then you really cant say anything because its lame to hate something just because a lot of people love it. just saying.
oooo i marked it bad am i not gonna "live my life to its full extent" ya right i now feel very accomplished for saying its bad so shut yor hatin mouth or join the fun!
They both have pros and cons. HP is more Twilight is more mature. They don't need to be rivals. I love them both. There us nothing wrong with that because both book series (or movie sagas) have good and bad points. I won't puck favorites, but this is crazy.
There is so much wrong with this whole entire debate. I mean, I really don't like Twilight at all. I dislike it so much I think I twitch a little when I think about it. However, I did give it all a try. I've read all the books, but when I reached number 4, I hated it. I even tried to rekindle my feelings for it before Breaking Dawn, and it just didn't work. And then all of the hype came about and it was just a downward spiral and now I can't stand it. I realize how bad the writing is and how selfish the story line is.
However, I am a huge Harry Potter fan. Not only do I really admire the writing style and J.K. Rowling's amazing ability to create a whole new world along side our own and develop such deep characters, but I have a lot of emotional attachment. My best friend and I met over this series.
So knowing what it is like on both sides, I do agree with this MLIA.
That aside, since I don't really know where I was going with that anyway, I'd like to throw a comment at those who are saying "grow up and stop reading fantasy books, they're all dumb, blah blah blah" I think we should all have a moment of silence for their inner child.
And I'd also like to point out that people really need to be careful about what they say. Like when a fan says something like "Twilight is better, BITCHZZZZZZ!!!" or the really fail-tastic post "Twilight is better than HP, so put that in your juice box and SUCK IT!" we're aren't going to take you seriously and it's just going to support our schema that Twilight fans are immature. However, there are plenty of comments by HP fans that would support the idea that we are all nerds and a-holes.
And finally... come on. Don't just say "Harry Potter sucks" or "Twilight sucks," give a good argument. And I feel totally secure in having a full out war of the worlds on the comment board, because guess what: MLIA!
hm , i reallly don't like harry potter. :S
i never really liked twilight either because so many greasy chinese kids were obsessed with it.. but i just started reading it.. and its actually good :D
lol am I the only one who likes both HP and Twiight? I'm not gonna get pissy about it like most Twihards do, but sometimes I get sad because all the Twilight lovers never know what I'm talking about whenever I relate things to HP, and the HP fans get mad at me everytime i mention the word Twilight(at least the one's I know). can't there be peace between the two for once? :/
Whether you like Twilight or not, go here:
http://stoney321.livejournal.com/317176.html
Now. Don't ask any questions. Just go. I promise you that you'll die laughing. Yes, even you, Twilight fans.
On an unrelated note, who came up with the term "Twihard"? I hope they realize that it gives easy access to the insult "Twitard". Yeah, not a very smart plan, whoever came up with that term.
ive sorta deccided ill just let ppl do what they want cuz some ppl r stubborn or they just have a strong opinion like me so whatever. im still totally and completely for harry potter but im kinda sorta over the fight
No. The story continues. Twilight is more mature that HP. I DO like harry potter (see my above story) but no need to diss this who don't.
Harry: more complicated
Twilght: more mature
Harry: more intellectual
Twilight: more appealing
Harry: a little Borong
Twilight: a little shallow.
Sees. Neither is better, Renalak. There different. Anyone gottya problem with that?
Harry Potter does pwn. but sadly there are a few book/movie-that-must-not-be-named posts. thankfully they are mostly about people making fun of book/movie-that-must-not-be-named
Can't you Twilight fans see you only like Twilight cause of those guys? I mean, Harry Potter is obviously so much better cause it has a GOOD PLOTLINE. It's not some random emo girl falling in love with a sparkling vampire. You just can't see Harry Potter's awesomeness because you're all Muggles. Harry Potter will perform Crucio on your precious Jacob and go Avada Kedavra on that sparkling vampire's sorry ass.
PS: Harry Potter has his own Werewolf and his own Vampire.
Remus Lupin and Rufus Scrimgeour.
PPS: JK Rowling can kick Stephanie Mayer's ass anytime. Anywhere.
Books that have antagonists' who's face is flat with slits for a nose automatically wins. Oh and the HP world isn't covered in various shades of blue as if stricken by frostbite or something.
I don't really like either at the moment, and I have good reason. I live in another country, and I am unable to get books in the language that I can read :(.(My life is still average, except for the language barrier). So I can't read Harry Potter, even though after hearing people's reviews I would kind of like to read it. I can get the movie- is it as good as the books? Twilight- I used to like it. I wasn't a fangirl- I never went to the premieres, never set my username or password as iloveedward or whatever. Then, after reading the books again for the tenth time, I realized that they were actually kind of boring. The characters were unrealistic and stuff like that. So, I gave up on it. Plus, I was forced to watch New Moon the other night, and the only entertaining part is the subtitles. (They were in Chinglish, look it up if you don't know what it means). Also, I think it is okay to disagree (my two best friends are HP lovers, and another friend loves Twilight :)) it's not okay to wish people would die because they read different books. A lot of people like both. They are completely different, but they are thrown together a lot because they are both fantasy and both very popular (maybe for different reasons?). This is just my opinion :)
i like both books, but harry potter is definetly better in general....and the lack of twilight posts is probably to do with the fact that twilight fans have their own website called 'MLIT - my life is twilight' =S
That would be because there's a MyLifeIsTwilight page, so no one feels the need to post it here. Huge fan of both, huger fan of HP...to all the HPLovers, try A Very Potter Musical on Youtube...awesomeness incarnate.
Just because you like twilight doesn't mean your not average. Get your heads outa your butts and accept it that just because you don't like something, other people can.
This is why I love this website!! Twilight is just the author playing on a little girl's fantasy and writing a book about a girls dream guy. and then putting that story in the girl's perspective so that they can pretend that theyre Bella, WHEN THEYRE NOT!!! Nobody is. She doesnt exist, nor does Edward, or Jacob, or any of it.
Twilight Is Super Sexist. The Movies Aren't As Bad But They Are In The Book. And The Books Are Baisically Bella Thinking About Shiz. Harry Potter Is More Real. None Of The Characters Are Perfect, People Who Are Good Die And Friends Fall Out. And Harry Potter Is So Clever And Mind Blowing
Sign in/Register to comment.